Evolution of the Russian-German Ethnopolitical System
https://doi.org/10.24833/2782-7062-2025-4-1-21-56
Abstract
The article provides analysis of Russian-German relations as a special ethnopolitical system. The author defines the ethnopolitical system at the interstate level as a relationship between two or more ethnic groups, which acquires a new quality expressed through the creation of a common political system. This system must include five components: a significant representation of one nation in another nation’s state; change in the quality of statehood of, at least, one of the participants; the emergence of new nations, intensive interaction between the participants and, finally, institutionalization. The author believes that Russian-German relations of the XVIII– XIX centuries were an example of such ethno-political system, which was characterized by all of the five listed characteristics. The development of this system included a number of stages: the emergence (the beginning of the XVIII century), the rise (XVIII – the beginning of the XIX century), zenith point (the second quarter of the XIX century), crisis (1850s), fall (the second half of the XIX century), and disintegration (the first half of the XX century) as the result of the two world wars. However, the modern ethnopolitical map of Eastern Europe, resulted from the Russian-German system, has a serious conflict potential.
About the Author
A. V. Fenenko
Lomonosov Moscow State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Alexey V. Fenenko, Doctor of Political Sciences, Professor of the Faculty of World Politics
Leninskie Gory st., 1, building 51, Moscow, 119234
References
1. Blackbourn, D. & Geoff, E. (1984). The Peculiarities of German History: Bourgeois Society and Politics in Nineteenth-Century Germany. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.
2. Breuer, St. (2010). Die Völkischen in Deutschland. Kaiserreich und Weimarer Republik. Darmstadt.
3. Eisfeld A. (1991). Die Rußlanddeutschen. Verlag: Langen. Müller, München.
4. Gagliardo, J.G. (1980). Reich and Nation. The Holy Roman Empire as Idea and Reality, 1763–1806. Indiana University Press.
5. Jarrett, M. (2013). The Congress of Vienna and Its Legacy: War and great power diplomacy after Napoleon. L.; N. Y.
6. Kann, R.A. (1974). History of the Habsburg Empire: 1526–1918. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
7. Menger, Ph. (2009). Die Heilige Allianz – ‚La garantie religieuse du nouveau système Européen‘? In Wolfram Pyta (Hrsg.): Das europäische Mächtekonzert. Friedens- und Sicherheitspolitik vom Wiener Kongreß 1815 bis zum Krimkrieg 1853. Stuttgart, pp. 209–236.
8. Nipperdey, Th. (1996). Germany from Napoleon to Bismarck, 1800-1866. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
9. Russland an der Ostsee. (2012). Imperiale Strategien der Macht und kulturelle Wahrnehmungsmuster (16. bis 20. Jahrhundert). Wien; Koln; Weimar.
10. Scherbakowa, I. (2020). Russland und Deutschland: Aspekte einer wechseivollen Beziehung. Stiftung Bundesprosident-Theodor-Heuss-Haus – Stuttgart.
11. Smelser, N.J. (1962). Theory of Collective Behavior. New York: Free Press.
12. Smith, A.D. (2009). Ethno-symbolism and Nationalism: A Cultural Approach. N.Y: Routledge. 184 p.
13. Spengler, O. 1933. Jahre der Entscheidung. Erster Teil. Deutschland und die weltgeschichtliche Entwicklung. C.H. Beck, München. S. 43–44.
14. Airapetov, O.R. (2017). Vneshniaia politika imperatora Nikolaia I. 1825–1855 [The Foreign Policy of Emperor Nicholas I. 1825–1855]. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole.
15. Andreeva, N.S. (2001). Kto takie «ostzeitsy»? [Who Are the “Ostsee”?] Voprosy istorii, 10, 173–175.
16. Andreeva, N.S. (2002). Status nemetskogo dvorianstva v Pribaltike v nachale XX v. [The Status of the German Nobility in the Baltics at the Beginning of the 20th Century] Voprosy istorii, 2, 44–61.
17. Anisimov, E.V. (1989). Vremia petrovskikh reform [The Time of Peter the Great’s Reforms]. Leningrad: Lenizdat.
18. Anisimov, E.V. (2004). Anna Ioannovna [Anna Ioannovna]. Moscow: Molodaia gvardiia.
19. Annenkova, E.A. & Golikov, Iu.P. (2004). Printsy Ol’denburgskie v Peterburge [The Princes of Oldenburg in St. Petersburg]. SPb.: Rostok.
20. Artamoshin, S.V. (2002). Ideinye istoki natsional-sotsializma [Ideological sources of national socialism]. Briansk.
21. Asaul, A.N., Dzhaman, M.A. & Shukanov, P.V. (2010). Tsivilizatsionnye aspekty razvitiia etnopoliticheskikh system [Civilization aspects of the development of ethnopolitical systems]. Vestnik grazhdanskikh inzhenerov, 4(25), 5–15.
22. Astvatsaturova, M.A. (2020). Etnopolitika kak iskusstvo vozmozhnogo: teoreticheskie idei i prakticheskie proektsii. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Ethnopolitics as the art of the possible: theoretical ideas and practical projections]. Moscow: Academia.
23. Bertalanfi, L. fon. (1969). Obshchaia teoriia sistem – kriticheskii obzor. Issledovaniia po obshchei teorii sistem: Sbornik perevodov [General systems theory – a critical review. Studies in general systems theory: Collection of translations]. General ed. and the introduction by V. N. Sadovsky and E.G. Yudin. MOSCOW: Progress. P. 23–82.
24. Bezymenskii, L.A. (1981). Razgadannye zagadki tret’ego reikha. Kniga ne tol’ko o proshlom. 1933–1941 [Solved mysteries of the Third Reich. A book not only about the past. 1933–1941]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo APN.
25. Bolotina, I.I. (2019). Etnopoliticheskaia sistema obshchestva: k opredeleniiu poniatiia [Ethnopolitical system of society: towards a definition of the concept]. Izvestiia Saratovskogo universiteta. Nov. ser. Ser. Sotsiologiia. Politologiia. Vol. 19, 3, 346–350.
26. Chesnokova, A.N. (2001). Nemtsy v Peterburge [The Germans in St. Petersburg]. SPb.: Satis.
27. Dugin, A.G. (1994). Konservativnaia revoliutsiia [Conservative Revolution]. Moscow. Arktogeia.
28. Easton, D. (2015). Podkhod k analizu politicheskikh system [An Approach to the Analysis of Political Systems]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriia 12: Politicheskie nauki, 5, 17–37.
29. Emel’ianov, E.P. (2014). Ostzeiskii vopros na stranitsakh slavianofil’skikh gazet (1861– 1868 gg.) [The Baltic Question in the Pages of Slavophile Newspapers (1861–1868)]. Dokument. Arkhiv. Istoriia. Sovremennost’, 14, 218–225.
30. Evstigneev, V. (1995). Germanskoe ob”edinenie: uroki dlia Rossii [German Unification: Lessons for Russia]. Mirovaia ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia, 10, 155–158
31. Fenenko, A.V. (2020). Istoriia mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii: 1648–1945 [History of International Relations: 1648–1945]. Moscow: Aspekt Press.
32. Filiushkin, A.I. (2008). Politicheskaia praktika moskovskikh vlastei v Livonii v pervye gody Livonskoi voiny (novye dokumenty) [Political Practice of the Moscow Authorities in Livonia in the First Years of the Livonian War (New Documents)]. Studia Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana, 1, 77–88.
33. Gavrilov (2011). Ostzeiskie nemtsy v Sankt-Peterburge. Rossiiskaia imperiia mezhdu shlezvigom i gol’shteinom. 1710-1918 [Baltic Germans in St. Petersburg. Russian Empire between Schleswig and Holstein. 1710-1918]. Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf.
34. Grigor’eva, A.A. (2011). Vneshniaia politika Avstro-Vengrii na Balkanakh i panslavizm (60-e gg. XIX – nachalo XX vv.) [Foreign Policy of Austria-Hungary in the Balkans and Pan-Slavism (1860s – early 20th centuries)]. Vestnik Irkutskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta, 7(54), 187–193.
35. Gubin, A.B. & Strokin, V.N. (2006). Kreposti i zamki Vostochnoi Prussii [Fortresses and Castles of East Prussia]. Kaliningrad: Iantarnyi skaz.
36. Iskiul’, S.N. (2007). Vneshniaia politika Rossii i germanskie gosudarstva (1801–1812) [Russia’s Foreign Policy and the German States (1801–1812)]. SPb.
37. Istoriia nemtsev Rossii. (2020) [History of the Germans of Russia]. German A.A. (red.). Moscow: MaVi grupp.
38. Kabuzan, V.M. (2003). Nemetskoiazychnoe naselenie v Rossiiskoi imperii i SSSR v XVIII-XX vekakh (1719-1989) [German-speaking population in the Russian Empire and the USSR in the 18th-20th centuries (1719-1989): Historical and statistical research]. Moscow.
39. Khavkin, B.L. (2014). Rossiia i Germaniia: 1900–1945 [Russia and Germany: 1900–1945]. Spletenie istorii. Moscow: Novyi khronograf.
40. Khoperskaia, L.L. (2013). Modeli konfliktnosti etnopoliticheskoi sistemy [Models of Conflict in the Ethnopolitical System]. Vestnik rossiiskoi natsii, 6(32).
41. Klimenik, E. (2018). Zamki Tevtonskogo ordena na territorii Rossii [Castles of the Teutonic Order on the territory of Russia]. Quaestio Rossica, 4, 1078–1092.
42. Kosolapov, N.A. (1996). Politiko-psikhologicheskaia tipologiia konflikta [Political and psychological typology of conflict]. Sotsiologicheskii zhurnal, 3-4.
43. Krasheninnikova, O.A. (2015). Sinodal’nye reformy petrovskogo vremeni i krizis traditsionnykh predstavlenii o sviatosti (Chast’ I) [Synodal reforms of the Peter the Great era and the crisis of traditional ideas about holiness (Part I)]. Kul’turnoe nasledie Rossii, 4, 49–55.
44. Kukharuk, A.V. (2012). Bol’shie kavaleriiskie manevry 1837 goda pod g. Voznesenskom v kontekste politiki nikolaevskoi Rossii. Velichie i iazvy Rossiiskoi imperii. Mezhdunarodnyi nauchnyi sbornik v chest’ 50-letiia O. R. Airapetova [Large cavalry maneuvers of 1837 near Voznesensk in the context of the policy of Nicholas’s Russia. The greatness and ulcers of the Russian empire. International scientific collection in honor of the 50th anniversary of O.R. Airapetov]. Moscow. P. 111–120.
45. Kupriianov V.A. (2018). Rossiia i Evropa v rannem i pozdnem slavianofil’stve (A.Khomiakov i V. I. Lamanskii) [Russia and Europe in early and late Slavophilism (A.S. Khomyakov and V.I. Lamansky)]. Solov’evskie issledovaniia, 2, 21–33.
46. Lannik, L.V. (2012). Germanskaia voennaia elita perioda Velikoi voiny i revoliutsii i «russkii sled» v ee razvitii [The German military elite during the Great War and revolution and the “Russian trace” in its development.]. Saratov: Izd-vo SGTU.
47. Lein, R. (1988). Publitsistika Tiutcheva v otsenke zapadnoevropeiskoi pechati kontsa 1840-kh – nach. 1850-kh gg [Tyutchev’s journalism in the assessment of the Western European press of the late 1840s – early 1850s]. Literaturnoe nasledstvo, 97. 231–252.
48. Lesment, L. (1963). Petr I i byvshii Tevtonskii orden [Peter I and the former Teutonic Order]. Istoricheskie zapiski, 73, 301–305.
49. Maksimychev, I. (1996). Germanskii faktor evropeiskoi bezopasnosti [The German factor in European security. International life]. Mezhdunarodnaia zhizn’, 11.
50. Melenberg, A.A. (1996). «Obida i gorech’, dolg i chest’». Ostzeiskie nemtsy v voine s Germaniei 1914-1918 gg. Moral’nyi aspect [“Resentment and bitterness, duty and honor”. Baltic Germans in the war with Germany 1914–1918. Moral aspect]. Rossiiskie nemtsy: Problemy istorii, iazyka i sovremennogo polozheniia. Moscow: Gotika. P. 284–298.
51. Molchanov, N.N. (1986). Diplomatiia Petra Pervogo [The diplomacy of Peter the Great]. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia.325–332.
52. Nemtsy v Rossii: istoriko-dokumental’noe izdanie (2004) [Germans in Russia: historical and documentary publication]. Otv. redaktor G.I. Smagina. SPb.: Liki Rossii.38–59.
53. Pavlov, N.V. (2019). Germaniia — Rossiia — ES: treugol’nik sotrudnichestva ili protivorechii? [Germany — Russia — EU: a triangle of cooperation or contradictions?]. Mirovaia ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia, 5, 67–75.
54. Rossiia i Germaniia v sisteme mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii: cherez veka istorii. (2012) [Russia and Germany in the System of International Relations: Through Centuries of History]. Ed. by V.N. Baryshnikova, A.Iu. Prokop’eva. SPb.
55. Selart, A. (2013). Ivan Groznyi, Kaizer Livonskii? K istorii vozniknoveniia idei o rossiiskogo vassal’nogo gosudarstva v Livonii [Ivan the Terrible, Kaiser of Livonia? On the History of the Emergence of the Idea of a Russian Vassal State in Livonia]. Studia Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana. Peterburgskie slavianskie i balkanskie issledovaniia, 2, 180–197.
56. Sharf, K. (2015). Ekaterina II. Germaniia i nemtsy [Catherine II. Germany and the Germans]. Moscow: Litagent «NLO».
57. Tarle, E.V. (1992). Napoleon [Napoleon]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo «Mysl’».
58. Tatishchev, S.S. (2013). Imperator Nikolai I i inostrannye dvory [Emperor Nicholas I and Foreign Courts. Historical Essays]. Istoricheskie ocherki. Sankt-Peterburg: Izdatel’stvo «Lan’».
59. Teilor, A.Dzh.P. (1958). Bor’ba za gospodstvo v Evrope: 1848–1918 gg [The Struggle for Dominance in Europe: 1848–1918]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Inostrannoi literatury.
60. Timofeev, P.P., Khorol’skaia M.V. (2021). Sravnitel’nyi analiz podkhodov Germanii i Frantsii k otnosheniiam s Rossiei [Comparative Analysis of the Approaches of Germany and France to Relations with Russia]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’, 5, 72–86.
61. Tishkov, V.A., Shabaev Iu.P. (2019). Etnopolitologiia: Politicheskie funktsii etnichnosti [Ethnopolitical Science: Political Functions of Ethnicit]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta.
62. Tsymburskii, V.L. (1995). Tiutchev kak geopolitik [Tyutchev as a Geopolitician. Social Sciences and Modernity]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’, 6, 86–98
63. Tsymburskii, V.L. (1997). Evropa–Rossiia: tret’ia osen’ sistemy tsivilizatsii [Europe–Russia: the Third Autumn of the System of Civilizations]. Polis. Politicheskie issledovaniia, 2, 56–71.
64. Tsymburskii, V.L. (1998). Kak zhivut i umiraiut mezhdunarodnye konfliktnye sistemy (sud’ba baltiisko-chernomorskoi sistemy v XVI-XX vv.) [How International Conflict Systems Live and Die (the Fate of the Baltic–Black Sea System in the 16th–20th Centuries)]. Polis. Politicheskie issledovaniia, 4.
65. Tverskoi, A. (1991). Rossiia i Germaniia: nam nuzhen vechnyi germano-russkii al’ians [Russia and Germany: We Need an Eternal German-Russian Alliance]. Golos Rossii, 1.
66. Vozgrin, V.E. (2008). Sud’ba shlezvig-gol’shteinskogo naslediia rossiiskikh imperatorov [The fate of the Schleswig-Holstein legacy of the Russian emperors]. Trudy kafedry istorii Novogo i noveishego vremeni, 2.
Review
For citations:
Fenenko A.V. Evolution of the Russian-German Ethnopolitical System. Governance and Politics. 2025;4(1):21-56. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2782-7062-2025-4-1-21-56
Views:
119
Email this article 